Site Search: WWW DTN

Tuesday, February 15, 2005

Historians or Fossils?

The Organization of American Historians has announced that it is moving its annual convention to San Jose to show solidarity with the hotel workers in San Francisco who are on strike against the Hilton where the meeting was originally planned. This will cost the OAH $450,000 because the change came late in the day and the contracts with the hotel had already been signed. According to the OAH website going to SF would also have cost them $500,000 because of unrented rooms. This is too confusing for me, but it's really beside the point. Professors are a privileged elite. Very privileged. Paid in the main by Hotel Worker's taxes (85% of the college population is in state institutions) they teach classes 6 hours a week, 8 months out of the year, for which they make six figure incomes and every seven years get 6 months paid vacation (in addition to the normal four months per year, which actually makes ten months during the sabbatical year). Professors can afford to take a little economic bath like this for their politics. But what politics! Unions are social fossils as everybody academics seems to know -- special interests whose main function is to create artifical labor shortages, drive up prices and make everybody poorer in the long run (witness how the greed of auto workers unions destroyed the dominance of their industry in the American and thus the worl d auto market, depriving generations of both income and jobs). Of course the Hotel Workers unions are run by radicals with politics (19th Century variety) very much akin to that of professional historians these days (as this account of the OAH in DiscoverTheNetwork will make clear). Which is the real reason for the solidarity.


3 Comments:

Anonymous said...

I can't log in on your new website

Tue Feb 15, 02:54:37 PM  
Anonymous said...

Wow. Some remarkable misinformation here. Where do you get your data showing that typical academic historians make "six figure incomes"? Average starting salaries are in the $40Ks and average overall salaries are in the $50Ks. Only a very few academic historians will ever see their salaries top $100,000, let alone the multiple hundreds of thousands you seem to imply. As for the months and months of "paid vacation" that you claim academic historians receive, perhaps you have heard of something called research and publishing - the principal condition of employment for most academic historians, and the required condition allowing those historians to be experts in the fields they teach, capable of conducting higher education rather than just a continuation of elementary learning. It actually takes time, effort, and often travel to conduct that research and do that writing, and, as such acctivity is the primary element of most historians' employment and directly informs their teaching, it seems not unreasonable to expect that the instutitions that employ them should support that activity.

I have no knoweldge of the situation in San Francisco or the OAH's reaction to it, and so I have nothing to say on those points. Perhaps you too should refrain from spouting off about the working conditions of historians, a point on which you clearly have less than no information or perspective.

Tue Feb 15, 04:01:08 PM  
Alec Rawls said...

Aaaah! Your white on gray is making my eyes do flip flops. The white looks brighter in some spots than others, with the bright spots swimming around, indicating that you are short circuiting my occipital lobe. Please change.

Tue Feb 15, 04:26:58 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Copyright 2003-2005 : DiscoverTheNetwork.org